November 5, 2026
When the former Dowling College campus in Oakdale came back on the market this spring, the first listing said the Idle Hour mansion was on the historic register and could qualify for tax breaks to "benefit a rehabilitation." Several outlets went further and reported that it had been on the National Register of Historic Places since 1979. Fire Island News later set the record straight. Neither the mansion nor any other building on the campus is on the National Register. They appear only on New York's state historic inventory.
Offers on the roughly 25-acre property on the Connetquot River were due June 30, 2026.
Maryann Almes, president of the Oakdale Historical Society, explained the mix-up to Fire Island News. In the 1970s, she said, New York State surveyed historic buildings and recorded each one's significance, materials and architect, "but it carries no weight except as an inventory. We probably have 70 buildings on this list in Oakdale alone."
According to Almes, the historical society suggested National Register listing to Mercury International after Mercury bought the property, and Dowling's own librarians had encouraged the college to apply before it closed. Neither one did.
The protection the mansion does have is a Planned Landmark Preservation overlay district, or PLP. Newsday reported that the town normally uses this tool for historic downtowns and neighborhoods with many older houses.
It is the second time the town has passed it. Islip approved a PLP for Idle Hour in 2018, but that version expired because the owners never filed the required covenants and restrictions with the county clerk. In October 2023, the Town Board passed it again by a 5-0 vote. Town officials said this version did not need Mercury's participation to take effect.
Idle Hour is not the only PLP in the area. Almes listed the Artist Community, Sagtikos Manor, the Idle Hour mansion and the Power House, which was Dowling's performing arts building, among the local PLPs. That means at least two buildings on this one campus are covered.
The listing for the 110-room, 45,000-square-foot Beaux-Arts mansion mentioned a ballroom with "a 24-karat gold leaf ceiling" and "an oak-paneled library imported from a French chateau." Long Island Business News reported eight buildings totaling about 239,790 square feet on the campus. Newsday listed a conservatory, a former residence hall, the performing arts center and three buildings that served educational and other purposes.
Tigar Realty did not publish an asking price. Williams told Newsday, "I think the market is going to tell us what it is worth." He said the estate is comparable locally perhaps only to Oheka Castle in Huntington, and he described "tremendous interest" from schools across the country and overseas, as well as possible hospitality and nursing-facility uses. He also said China Orient Asset Management, which owns a majority stake in owner Mercury International, "always intended to sell the property" as part of liquidating Mercury's portfolio.
The mansion has already been reused several times. Almes listed its past lives for Fire Island News: "A cult compound, National Dairy headquarters, a hotel, and a college; she is a survivor." It started as the centerpiece of William K. Vanderbilt's 900-acre Idle Hour estate. Dowling opened on the riverbank in 1968 and closed in June 2016 after declaring bankruptcy.
Here are some key moments since Dowling closed:
Through those years the county showed interest too. In November 2025, Fire Island News reported Legislator Anthony Piccirillo saying Mercury had not answered Suffolk County's letter of intent about a possible open-space purchase. Almes described vandals spray-painting graffiti, breaking stained glass windows and sawing through doors. She also told Newsday the mansion "remains sturdy."
Oakdale Civic Association president Ray Carta told Newsday in April, "I think the general opinion is they would look for it to be a school again, as opposed to a hospital or some kind of hospitality" business. He connected the campus to the rest of the hamlet, saying a new educational use "might very well help" fill other vacant properties, especially along Montauk Highway.
Almes told the same reporter that keeping the building exactly as it is was never realistic. "The way to preserve something in today's world is to reappropriate it for today's world," she said. "It's never going to be a museum." By June, she told Fire Island News she was "cautiously optimistic."
The campus is private property, so the view from Idle Hour Boulevard and from the Connetquot is as close as most neighbors get. For more of what Oakdale has to offer outside these gates, our Oakdale neighborhood page and our guide to a fall weekend in Connetquot River State Park are good places to start. If you own a home in the Idle Hour section, our recent piece on the new sewer line and selling timelines covers the other big change in your part of town.
The Idle Hour mansion has stood on the Connetquot for about 125 years. If you live in Idle Hour and are wondering how the campus's future fits into your own plans, Annette Mina is always glad to talk it through with you. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
With decades of experience, trusted market expertise, and a client-first approach, Annette Mina is dedicated to your success every step of the way.