October 15, 2026
Downtown Bay Shore has had a busy year of openings, and most of them come from people Bay Shore already knows. One local ice cream shop opened a second location on Main Street. A neighborhood pizzeria opened in the space where an old favorite closed. A restaurant marking 12 years on East Main Street is about to move a few blocks west into a building three times the size. Both of the 2025 arrivals on Main Street took over rooms that diners already knew. Very few of the spots that opened in the last year or so are true newcomers. Mostly the street is reshuffling and adding on.
That changes how a list of new places reads. Here's how the past year lines up when you sort each address by what was there before.
| Address | What's there now | What came before |
|---|---|---|
| 55 W. Main St. | Verde's new home, still under construction | Peninsula, an Asian fusion restaurant |
| 45 W. Main St. | Kismet Coffee, opened September 2025 | ITA Kitchen |
| 52 E. Main St. | Magnolias, opened September 2025 | King's Chophouse |
| 17 E. Main St. | Coyle's Ice Cream, opened July 10, 2026 | A second shop for a Bay Shore business started in 1985 |
| 73 Howells Rd. | Villa Roma, opened April 20, 2026 | Marcony Pasta & Pizza, and before that Joe's Pizza & Pasta |
The clearest example of the pattern is Verde Kitchen & Cocktails. In October, Verde marks its 12th anniversary at 70 East Main Street. Meanwhile its owners are finishing a new location at 55 West Main Street, in the building that used to house Peninsula. Greater Long Island reported in August that the move has been close to five years in the making.
The new building is a big step up in size. Anthony Tartaglia, president and founder of Bay Shore-based Costa Verde Hospitality, told Greater Long Island that the restaurant is "going from 2,700 square feet to about 9,000 square feet." The plans include multiple rooms, catering space, a rooftop bar and a hidden mezcal bar in the back. A 12-foot wood-fired grill, which the owners call "the backbone of the food program," has already arrived. Verde's signature glass greenhouse is being recreated too, and this time it sits at the front of the West Main Street property instead of the rear.
"Now it looks like a restaurant," Tartaglia told the outlet. "So the end is near."
He also said that he, his brother Andy and business partner Joe Mele had not set an opening date as of late August. They are still aiming to open in 2026, a goal Tartaglia noted is "what the sign on the front of the building says," adding, "That sign's been up for like two or three years."
The name is still unsettled. A new name, Para Todo Bien, was announced with the move in 2023. Then a 2025 Greater Long Island report said the owners had put the change on hold and planned to keep Verde. Since then, the header on Verde's own website has gone back to reading "COMING SOON: PARA TODO BIEN." Until the doors open, nobody outside the restaurant group can say for sure which name goes over the West Main Street entrance.
The original restaurant at 70 East Main is still open daily. No plan for that space has been announced since the owners said in 2023 that they were keeping it for the time being and hadn't decided what to do with it.
The Verde move points west along Main Street. The Coyle's expansion points the other way, from a side street onto the main drag. Coyle's Ice Cream was founded in Bay Shore in 1985, and its original shop is at 75 Howells Road. That's 41 years of the same local name. On July 10, 2026, Patch reported that Coyle's was opening its second Bay Shore location at noon at 17 E. Main St., staying open until midnight Friday through Sunday. Summer hours rarely last, so check the shop's social pages before planning a late-night cone in the colder months.
With the Main Street shop, a name Bay Shore has known for four decades now sits on the downtown dining block.
Back on Howells Road, an address just down from Coyle's original shop has its own comeback story. Villa Roma, an Italian restaurant and pizzeria at 73 Howells Road, opened quietly on April 20, 2026, and held its grand opening on July 10. That was the same day Coyle's opened on Main Street.
The space was most recently Marcony Pasta & Pizza. Before that it was Joe's Pizza & Pasta, a longtime Bay Shore staple that Greater Long Island noted had closed four years before Villa Roma arrived. Owner John Parini told the outlet that the community had "really shown a lot of support" without any advertising. "A lot of customers have told me so far that it's great to have a pizzeria in town again that reminds them of the old Joe's," he said.
According to the same report, Parini wanted to do more than reopen the location. He also wanted to bring back parts of the neighborhood pizzeria that many residents still remember. Here, a new business is deliberately building on an old room's reputation.
The same thing happened on Main Street itself in the fall of 2025.
Both openings were covered by Greater Long Island. Together with Verde's planned move, three of the four Main Street addresses in the table at the top have changed hands or will soon. A morning coffee at 45 West Main and a martini at 52 East Main both happen in rooms that already had a following.
Some downtown businesses really are new this year, and they opened mostly on the side streets and around the station area rather than on Main Street itself.
So the Main Street storefronts mostly stayed with names Bay Shore already knew, while the truly new businesses settled a block or two away. One way to read that is that the best-known storefronts went to the businesses with the most local history.
The downtown calendar for the next few weeks, as listed by the Chamber of Commerce of Greater Bay Shore:
This fall's Twilight Market season began on September 18 at the Bay Shore Bandshell, with SouthBound playing the kickoff, according to a Patch calendar listing. The Chamber's listings for the October 16 and 23 markets don't name a venue, and the other events don't list one either, so check the Chamber calendar for locations before you head out. These are live listings, and dates and times can change.
A Twilight Market Friday also makes an easy evening downtown. Coffee on West Main or a scoop on East Main, dinner at Magnolias or the Verde that's still running at 70 East Main, and a walk west past the construction at 55 West Main to see how close the greenhouse is to done. For more on the waterfront side of town, our guide to Bay Shore's waterfront and downtown lifestyle covers the blocks south of Main Street, and our Bay Shore neighborhood page collects the rest.
The two answers still missing are an opening date at 55 West Main and a plan for 70 East Main once Verde leaves. If you'd like to talk through what the changes along Main Street mean for your own street or a home you're thinking about, Annette Mina is always glad to talk Bay Shore. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
With decades of experience, trusted market expertise, and a client-first approach, Annette Mina is dedicated to your success every step of the way.