White clapboard home entry with a navy door, paired sidelights, brick steps and autumn oakleaf hydrangea.

Sayville Main Street Fire, Nearly Two Years Later: Where Shops Stand

October 8, 2026

On August 11, Sayville Running Company posted a short note to its followers: "We'll be closed Thursday and Friday. Looking forward to seeing you Saturday ... ON MAIN STREET!" That Saturday was August 15, 2026, and the shop reopened at 19 Main St. for the first time since the fire, nearly two years earlier.

The fire started around 5:40 p.m. on Friday, October 25, 2024, in the vacant former Café Joelle storefront at 25 Main St. Fire department and Suffolk County police reports later filed in court could not determine a cause. With the second anniversary three weeks away, the block hasn't recovered as one unit. Each building has moved on its own schedule, set by its own landlord, and two of the businesses that burned out have rebuilt their customer base a short walk away on Railroad Avenue.

Where Everyone From That Block Is Today

The Greater Sayville Chamber of Commerce published a list of affected parties after the fire. Here is where each one stands as of early October 2026, based on the most recent reporting.

Business Before the fire Where it is now
Sayville Running Company 19 Main St. Back at 19 Main St. since Aug. 15, 2026
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique 23 Main St. 106 Railroad Ave., open since Aug. 16, 2025
Boris' Barber Shop Same building as Paper Doll 46 Railroad Ave.
Hammer & Stain 15 N. Main St. Rebuilding at 15 N. Main St.; classes running at its Ronkonkoma studio
Café Joelle 25 Main St., vacated before the fire Had opened a location off Main Street before the fire
Former 23–25 Main St. building Café Joelle site, Paper Doll, Boris' Demolished January 2026; lot is vacant

The list also named The Crushed Olive and the upstairs offices of Adrian Fields Counseling. The Crushed Olive's website currently lists stores in Babylon, Commack, Stony Brook and Halesite, with no Sayville location.

Railroad Avenue Picked Up Two of Them

Paper Doll Vintage Boutique and Boris' Barber Shop shared a subdivided building with the former café. Newsday reported that all three were completely burned out. Neither had a building to go back to, and both moved to Railroad Avenue.

Boris' was cutting hair at 46 Railroad Ave. by November 2024, only weeks after the fire. Paper Doll owner Dominique Maciejka took longer. Her store at 23 Main St. was destroyed, and she reopened at 106 Railroad Ave. on August 16, 2025. During that stretch, Newsday reported, local kids ran lemonade stands for her and people donated vintage clothing to help rebuild her stock.

Community money helped pay for those moves. Chamber administrator Eileen Tyznar started the Main Street Fire Relief Fund, and the chamber pledged that every dollar would go to affected business owners. By November 20, 2024, the fund had raised more than $100,000, and Newsday reported it was being used for rent, deposits on new locations and replacement stock. That came to $15,000 for each of the seven businesses Newsday counted. A separate GoFundMe for Paper Doll passed $35,000 within about a week of the fire.

Each Building Is on Its Own Schedule

The three addresses still on Main Street show why the block has been slow to fill back in. Each building has a different owner, a different amount of damage and a different status.

19 Main St. was partially damaged. Co-owner Brendan Barrett told Newsday the building was rebuilt to its original structure with a new roof and an accessible bathroom. He and co-owner Michael Nolan planned to lay out the store "a little differently" with new fixtures. The old faux-brick slatwall was damaged in the fire and couldn't be replaced. Barrett said the contractor and landlord kept them updated throughout. Tyznar, now the chamber's president, said permitting and the hard winter probably stretched the timeline. In the meantime the shop ran out of a warehouse at 35 Overton St., which Barrett said drew less foot traffic than Main Street. He credited regular customers with keeping the business afloat. "We knew it would be longer than we thought, but we didn't think it would be this long," he said.

15 N. Main St., home of Hammer & Stain, has a different landlord from the destroyed building next door. Owner Sandra Bernius told Greater Long Island the building stayed structurally sound, but the front of the shop took heavy water, smoke and soot damage, and much of what was inside had to be thrown out. For about 10 months she held classes in a rebuilt back room. In January, Newsday reported that room had become too cold to use around Christmas, even with temporary heat, and the Sayville location was "100% closed."

23–25 Main St. was razed in January 2026. Newsday reported that the property is the subject of a lawsuit, and an attorney involved in the case said the site would stay undeveloped "for the foreseeable future." In its August update, Newsday quoted Tyznar as saying the rebuild of those storefronts is "going to be a while." Since February, no public reporting has described a plan, an application or a temporary use for the lot. Curinne Polizzi, who owns the nearby Ivory & Main bridal boutique, put her outlook this way in February: "eventually, it will get back to that Main Street where everyone can walk around." Newsday also reported that Paper Doll's goal is to eventually rebuild on the old Main Street site.

What's Still Coming to 15 North Main

In August, Bernius said Hammer & Stain was tentatively aiming to reopen in early October, calling it a "rebirth." On October 2, the business posted that it hadn't shared much about construction at the Sayville store, and its Sayville page still sends visitors to the rear entrance. Treat the reopening date as open until the studio announces it.

Bernius described what the rebuilt studio will offer:

  • Glass projects, including mosaics and fused glass
  • Familiar wood projects and chunky blanket workshops
  • An expanded retail section with custom orders, grab-and-go gifts and items you can personalize in the store
  • Holiday parties, which the studio plans to start hosting in November

Some of the new crafts have already been tried out at the company's Ronkonkoma studio, which opened at Station Yards in October 2025. The company's October 2 post said the Ronkonkoma studio was open that weekend for Casual Craft Saturday. Our look at what's already running at Station Yards covers what else is there. Bernius said many of her staff are coming back to Sayville.

The Rest of Downtown Kept Changing

While these three addresses waited on contractors, the courts and permits, other storefronts turned over around them. Openings in 2026:

  • Off the Bay opened in the former Sayville Bait & Tackle space at 220 N. Main St. with a soft opening in March. The partners are Michael Jordan, Robert DelGiorno and Shaun Ihne.
  • Saturday Candy Co. opened its second shop at 12 Gillette Ave. just before Easter. Julia Brandt runs it with her husband, Bo.
  • Fame + Rebel, a women's boutique, is open at 10 Main St.

Some longtime names closed. Crosstown Chef at 399 North Main St. shut in March, about six years after taking over the Fancy Nancy Country Store space. Metros on Main, which many people still know as Sayville Pizza, served its last customers on Sunday, September 13. "Thank you Sayville for 65 years of support," the restaurant wrote on Instagram. The clothing shop South Quarter also announced in January that it would close after nearly five years.

Each change follows its own lease and owner, just like the burned block. For a broader picture of the town around Main Street, see our Sayville neighborhood page and our earlier day in Sayville.

On the Downtown Calendar

The chamber's FallFest, planned for October 18, was canceled. The chamber says it will return next year. The chamber's October general meeting is October 13 at 7 p.m. at The Cull House, 75 Terry Road. Shop Small Saturday and Miracle on Main are set for November 28, with November 29 as the rain date. The chamber notes that dates can change until the Town of Islip permit is issued and the flyer is posted.

If you own a home near downtown Sayville and want to know how changes on Main Street are showing up in nearby sales, Annette Mina can walk you through the recent numbers. Let's Connect.

Work With Annette

With decades of experience, trusted market expertise, and a client-first approach, Annette Mina is dedicated to your success every step of the way.