Shingle-house entry with a navy glazed door, bluestone steps, and copper-leaved shrubs.

West Sayville Halloween Boat Burning 2026: Monitor II's Ferry History

October 1, 2026

"Come bid Monitor II a fond farewell." That's how the Long Island Maritime Museum is describing this year's Halloween Boat Burning, and the phrasing undersells what's actually going up in flames on the museum's dock this October. Monitor II isn't a decommissioned rowboat or a donated wreck nobody can identify. It's a working piece of Fire Island transit history, built specifically to ferry passengers across the Great South Bay during a decade when two rival family businesses were fighting in court over who got to carry them.

The museum holds its 35th Annual Halloween Boat Burning on October 24, with a rain date of October 25. Gates open at 5:00 p.m. on the museum grounds at 88 West Avenue, and the night runs on live entertainment, gourmet food trucks, and a raffle boat drawing, all for five dollars a person, with children under five admitted free. For a lot of West Sayville residents, this is already a fixture on the fall calendar, the kind of thing you show up to without checking the details twice. This year the details are worth a second look.

What's Actually Burning This Year

Monitor II first went into service on the bay in the early 1960s, custom-built for the Sayville-to-Fire-Island run. Her hull is made of overlapping sheets of marine plywood, a construction method the U.S. Navy refined for PT boats during World War II, and the museum notes her bow curves still echo that lineage. She wasn't the first boat on this route. That distinction belongs to a ferry called Mildred, which started carrying passengers from Brown's River in Sayville back in 1894. But Monitor II is the last of the wooden ferries that made that same crossing to Cherry Grove and Fire Island Pines, and she's been sitting at the museum's docks long enough that most people who pass her probably assume she's always been a static exhibit rather than a boat that used to actually run somewhere.

The Ferry War Nobody Remembers

Here's the part that turns a bonfire into a history lesson. In the early 1960s, two separate family-run ferry companies were both hauling passengers from Sayville out to Fire Island, competing for the same riders headed to the same two destinations. When one side added a near-sister vessel called Merrimack II to expand capacity, the rivalry escalated far enough that it ended up in court. The resolution split the market cleanly: one company would serve Fire Island Pines, the other would serve Cherry Grove, and each family stuck to its lane from then on.

The arrangement held for two decades, until the 1980s AIDS crisis hit both companies' ridership and revenue hard. By 1983, one of the two operators sold its docking rights and its boat, Monitor II, to the Stein family's Sayville Ferry Service, consolidating a route that had once needed two competing fleets to run. Local kids who grew up working around the boats during that era went on to become the captains, mechanics, and boatbuilders who still work these waters. Monitor II carried that whole arc on her deck, from a two-company feud to a single surviving operator, before she eventually came to rest at the museum.

That's the boat West Sayville sets on fire every October, and this year it's specifically her turn.

How To Actually Spend The Night

The Halloween Boat Burning has a simple shape once you've been once, but the format is worth laying out plainly if you haven't:

  • Date: October 24, with a rain date of October 25
  • Time: Gates open at 5:00 p.m.
  • Cost: $5 per person, children under 5 free
  • What's included: live entertainment, gourmet food trucks, and a raffle drawing for a new wooden boat built by the museum's own boat shop volunteers
  • Where: Long Island Maritime Museum, 88 West Avenue, West Sayville

The event draws support each year from the West Sayville Fire Department and Suffolk County's Parks and Fire, Rescue and Emergency Services departments, along with Community Ambulance Company, which is part of why the burn itself is handled as a controlled, supervised event on the museum's waterfront rather than an open bonfire. Costumes are part of the tradition too, so if you've got a Halloween outfit sitting in a closet from a party you skipped, this is the low-key place to actually wear it.

Where To Eat Before Or After

The museum sits close enough to West Sayville's small commercial stretch that dinner doesn't require much of a detour. The Cull House has been serving full-service seafood in the area since 1977, and it's an easy stop if you want a sit-down meal before the gates open. Off The Block Kitchen & Meats and The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails both come up consistently in local reviews as reliable options within a short drive, and if seafood is the point of the evening anyway, Kingston's Fish Market and Kingston's Clam Bar are both named among the area's better seafood spots. For something quieter after the fire's died down, Scotty's Pub sits along the golf course and works as a low-key nightcap stop rather than a full dinner destination.

None of this requires planning a whole evening around the drive. West Sayville is compact enough that dinner, the bonfire, and a drink afterward can all happen within a few minutes of each other.

The Season Closing Around It

The Boat Burning also marks something like a seasonal bookend for the museum's calendar. Its Thursdays on the Bay concert series, where visitors bring a beach chair and a picnic to listen to music along the water, runs through the warmer months and wraps before the burning takes over as the marquee fall event. The museum's Seafood Festival, its biggest annual fundraiser, already happened back in August. By the time October rolls around, the boat burning is effectively the last big gathering on the grounds before the museum settles into its quieter winter hours.

If you've lived in West Sayville long enough to have caught a few of these fires already, this year gives you a reason to actually read the placard next time instead of walking past it. Monitor II isn't just this year's designated bonfire. She's a piece of a ferry rivalry that shaped how two Fire Island communities got their names attached to competing dock schedules, and she spent two decades of her working life carrying that history back and forth across the bay before she ever came to rest at the museum.

If you've got your own memory of riding Monitor II back when she still ran the bay, or a Boat Burning story from a past October, Annette Mina would genuinely like to hear it. Let's Connect.

Work With Annette

With decades of experience, trusted market expertise, and a client-first approach, Annette Mina is dedicated to your success every step of the way.